macintosh.world | Log In | Register

Today | News | Books | Recipes
Notes | QuickTake | Wiki | Browse
Maps | Reference | Reddit | YouTube
Chat | Games | About

Back to HN

Toyota, Nissan, and Honda to standardize parts to lower costs

by zdw | 680 points | 410 comments | 2026-11-21 22:04:56 Central

Open Source Link | Read Source Here

Open on Hacker News

Comments

wcfields
They're (the Japanese makers) are getting cooked by the
Chinese makers like BYD who make 75%-85% of their parts
in-house[1].Depending on the car, some estimates say that
only the windows and tires are the only pieces that come
from outside suppliers.[1]
https://www.electrichybridvehicletechnology.com/features/f
ea...

  > cloudbonsai
This take is somewhat off. The basic context here is
that Japanese automakers experienced tremendous supply
chain stress due to recent geopolitical events (such
as the US-Iran war; you should remember the Strait of
Hormuz crisis!)So JAMA (Japanese automakers'
industrial association) asked what they could do.
Their answer was to standardize basic components so
that they could reduce bottlenecks.

    > > jfsebastian
Toyota decided after the events of Fukushima that
their supply-chain has to be way more resistant
against external events. I assume they build up up
to 6 months (I even remembered 18 months, but
couldn't find evidence) of parts to make sure
their production is not falling apart.

      > > > throwaway85825
The fukushima plant workers performed
incredibly during the disaster. They harvested
batteries from the parking lot and used fire
engine pumps. An excellent example of anti
fragility.

        > > > > sandworm101
The logistics impact on toyota was from
the area closure and evac, not anything to
do with the goings on at the actual
nuclear plant. Any number of disasters
could have had a similar impact.

        > > > > Geezus_42
None of that has anything to do with the
comment you replied to. Despite their
valiant efforts, it was still a disaster.

          > > > > > janderson215
It's also not what antifragile means.
    > > sigmoid10
If everyone uses the same parts and components,
wouldn't that put even more stress on their
respective supply chains in times of crisis? I
feel like it would be better to diversify parts
and their production more globally, to become
independent of individual geopolitical hotspots.

      > > > andy_ppp
If you have 10 suppliers all making the same
wind screen wiper motor it's obviously better
and cheaper than 10 suppliers all making
different versions of essentially the same
thing. You might argue that this will
eventually lead to fewer suppliers because one
will manage to undercut the others. Maybe it's
on the car manufacturers to source from a
wider net even if things are slightly more
expensive to keep a stronger ecosystem.

        > > > > cloudbonsai
The parent comment is schematically
correct. Right now each automaker uses its
own quality standard for steel. So it's
non-trivial for a steel plant to supply
materials to both Toyota and Honda.Note
that the scope of standardization is
fairly limited at least for now. JAMA's
initial targets are steel, resins and
wires.

          > > > > > formerly_proven
It's curious that the Japanese OEMs
are so far behind on this.

            > > > > > > throwaway85825
Are they? Western OEMs are jack
welch asset light businesses that
just assemble vehicles from tier 1
suppliers. A tier one supplier
even owns the final assembly plant
for one Mercedes model. All
mercedes provides is the badge and
mountains of paperwork.

            > > > > > > stasomatic
You mean the G-Wagon made by Magna
Styer in Austria? If so, they are
have always been made there.

            > > > > > > formerly_proven
The german ones at least are very
heavy on industry standardization,
they have their own
ISO/DIN-but-for-cars (VDA), which
inspired equivalent standards now
used by Chinese OEMs.

            > > > > > > throwaway85825
Industry standards are paperwork
companies, which doesnt inherently
imply they actually manufacture
anything themselves. And usually
standards are heavily tied into
FMVSS or EPA regulations. Lots of
busy work with nothing produced,
but it sure employs a lot of
politicians relatives.

        > > > > Geezus_42
But since there's only one supplier,
they'll jack the prices way up and that
will get passed to consumers.

          > > > > > chiph
Not necessarily one supplier, but one
design.Toyota did that for years with
their window switch assembly. You saw
the same design on a Corolla and a
Lexus, but the Lexus would have a
nicer finish.

            > > > > > > Geezus_42
But that is a single manufacturer
selling to a single buyer. What is
being described is a monopoly
where a single manufacturer
produces the parts for multiple
customers. It's not the same
situation.

        > > > > sigmoid10
>If you have 10 suppliers all making the
same wind screen wiper motor it's
obviously better and cheaper than 10
suppliers all making different
versionsThat's a non sequitur. At least
unless the whole world switches to the
same standard or they all only had one
customer to begin with. If those suppliers
have to change, adapt or extend their
production to accommodate a standard while
still shipping their original product to
other customers, the end result will be
more expensive. And it would have done
nothing to relieve the geopolitical issues
brought up by the parent comment.

          > > > > > awesome_dude
Wait - you're saying that because they
all change their product, that even
though their market size jumps (they
don't sell to one car manufacturer,
they can sell to all) that that
automagically increases costs?Can I
introduce you to peaks, troughs and
shoulders?You're likely to respond
that the market stays the same,
because its now split up by the wiper
manufacturers that were creating
specialised systems - fair.Except
nobody is ordering in an even cadence
across the year, most orders will be
higher at some points, and lower at
others. And, the success of a given
wiper manufacturer would be coupled
hard to the success of the car
(model[s]) they build for.Now, the
wiper manufacturers will be able to
plan their output, coupled not to a
given model(s) success, instead to the
Japanese car industries success
overall (less variable, still not
deterministic though, to be fair)That
brings us to the peaks and troughs
section - they dont have to have
capacity for the peaks, which goes to
waste (idle plant/staff) during the
troughs, instead the other customers
will fill the shoulders (more even
output)That's significant cost savings
for the homogenised (wiper)
manufacturers, with the one off cost
of refitting their lines (which will
be cheaper to do than normal
because... multiple of them will be
doing it...

            > > > > > > sigmoid10
>even though their market size
jumpsWhy would it jump? Overall
demand doesn't increase under the
given assumptions. They'd be
selling the same thing in a
different form. Producing more
forms costs more money.

            > > > > > > awesome_dude
> (they don't sell to one car
manufacturer, they can sell to
all)And also:> You're likely to
respond that the market stays the
same, because its now split up by
the wiper manufacturers that were
creating specialised systems -
fair.> Except nobody is ordering
in an even cadence across the
year, most orders will be higher
at some points, and lower at
others. And, the success of a
given wiper manufacturer would be
coupled hard to the success of the
car (model[s]) they build
for.Please try to have an honest
read before misrepresenting posts.

      > > > numpad0
Just imagine the Apollo 13 carbon dioxide
scrubber cartridge situation, but it's
literally for 30k parts. Of which ~10k are ICE
related.(so, an EV without powertrain may have
up to 30% less parts, or as many as 70% as an
ICE. not like 10x less, at all. And this is
before adding back in 7000 battery cells each
made of few parts and the motor itself so...
the parts count is actually the same?
Interesting)

      > > > LadyCailin
Standardizing parts does not imply
centralizing production. That may happen due
to the inherent pressure to monopolize things,
which companies seem to face, but they are
orthogonal.

        > > > > falserum
If there is cause-effect relation, are
they actually orthogonal?

          > > > > > Retric
The cause effect is unrelated to
standardization here. Having 2
different types of steel each of which
have a single supplier is not
meaningfully different than having 1
type of steel and a single supplier.

      > > > serial_dev
Which one is easier to get, a USB-C cable or
(insert esoteric cable config)?

        > > > > TeMPOraL
OTOH, once you have a source for "USB-C
cable" / "(insert esoteric cable config)",
which one's gonna be more reliable
experience ordering repeatedly?Chances
are, the esoteric crap comes from one
plant and has one major customer, so every
bit is gonna be the same.With USB-C
cables, Who the fkkk knows what you'll
get? The only bit guaranteed identical
between two USB-C cables is the connector
shape. Everything else is lottery.At this
point I think EU should introduce a
mandatory labeling scheme for USB-C
cables, so that each cable is stamped both
on packaging and on the cable itself, with
the very same stuff USB-C cable tester
shows it. And since the "better" cables
have chips on board, we could enroll them
in the same "Battery Passport" / "Digital
Product Passport" thing, with steep fines
to all the importers or resellers who
waste people's time selling fake cables.

          > > > > > awesome_dude
> which one's gonna be more reliable
experience ordering
repeatedly?Conversely - in the
esoteric world, if the manufacturer is
disinclined to produce "quality" -
what exactly are you going to do about
it?

            > > > > > > Geezus_42
What are you going to do about a
decline in quality or an increase
in prices if there is a single
manufacturer?

  > gniv
I don't think this is a parts story fundamentally. The
Japanese are behind in electric vehicles. They are
trying to survive using these tricks but unless they
start getting serious about making EVs they are
doomed.

    > > drnick1
In some markets, the US notably, electric cars are
kind of a curiosity. I think the main issue is
that, at the low end, the total cost of ownership
of an entry level Tesla or similar is rather high
relative to something like a hybrid Corolla. At
the high end, electric trucks are insanely
expensive and less practical than gas trucks.

      > > > AnthonyMouse
> I think the main issue is that, at the low
end, the total cost of ownership of an entry
level Tesla or similar is rather high relative
to something like a hybrid Corolla.The problem
there is you're comparing a Corolla to a Tesla
and not e.g. a Chevy Bolt, which has a lower
TCO than both.> At the high end, electric
trucks are insanely expensive and less
practical than gas trucks.There is a reason
companies like Amazon use electric delivery
trucks and it's not because they're
impractical.The main issue with trucks is that
to give an electric truck a reasonable range
when hauling a load, it needs a much bigger
battery, and then to justify that you have to
be actually using it as a truck full-time
rather than as a truck-shaped car. Which is
fully justified when you are, because then the
fuel savings are enormous.Whereas the people
not really using it as a truck don't really
need the bigger battery and then it doesn't
have to cost that much. And even that isn't
going to matter if the battery prices keep
going down.The other option which the US
companies seem to be leaning into is to use
the smaller battery and offer a range extender
that runs on gas, which is a hybrid in a sense
but it's more like an EV with a slot to put a
gas generator.

        > > > > close04
Maybe this is a terminology issue but
isn't Amazon using electric vans? I
understood the trucks GP talks about are
the Ford F150 Lightning and the likes
(justifies the high end label).For city
deliveries an EV is a no-brainer. Short
distances with lost of start-stops, lots
of idling, perfect for an electric motor.
An electric F150 will have very different
usage pattern and TCO.

        > > > > verisimi
> There is a reason companies like Amazon
use electric delivery trucks and it's not
because they're impractical.Right. It's
subsidies/incentives. And, of course,
operating within the legal/governance
structure, you can 'fine' the vehicles you
don't like - have special clean air zones
with fees for entry, high tax for
oil/petrol, etc.I hope you didn't mean
this was something to do with costs. It's
just the government using licensing, laws,
taxes, etc to direct proceedings as they
want - nothing to do with the underlying
costs.

          > > > > > AnthonyMouse
Large delivery trucks get like 10 MPG
when they run on gasoline, and even
worse than that in stop and go.
Operating one full time puts its fuel
consumption in the tens of thousands
of dollars a year. Eliminating two
thirds of that by using EVs pays for
itself straight away without any
subsidies.

            > > > > > > bluGill
More like 4mpg. On diesel they get
10mpg. Which is why diesel has
long been popular in trucks

      > > > eru
> I think the main issue is that, at the low
end, the total cost of ownership of an entry
level Tesla or similar is rather high relative
to something like a hybrid Corolla.The main
issue is that the US effectively bans imports
of electric cars from the most efficient
suppliers on the planet.

      > > > adrianN
An entry level Tesla is kind of a luxury car
though. It costs twice as much as a Dacia
Spring and Chinese models are much better
value, or so I've heard.

        > > > > speedgoose
It depends what you value. If you value
software quality and UX too, Tesla still
has a competitive offer.

          > > > > > Lio
Tesla also comes with massive
political baggage in the form of
Musk.His interference in elections and
the war in Ukraine hasn't gone
unnoticed in many markets. Tesla comes
with weaker residual value because of
the brand damage.Now that other
manufacturers are moving away from
soft-screens towards tactile controls
software UX is much less important
too.Personally, I'd much rather have
"knob per function" than have to go
menu diving through a GUI at
80mph.There's many great alternatives
now that really are great value. i.e.
Renault, Nissan, Skoda, VW, BMW,
Dacha.

            > > > > > > kajumix
Have you tried the self-driving on
the latest hardware on Teslas?
It's so good, it will blow your
mind. I have owned a Y since
January this year and have put
around 13k miles on it so far. 98%
of them are self-driven. I truly
never want to go back to a car
without this feature.

            > > > > > > fodkodrasz
Support the free world: Just buy
European. Or a Japanese (I don't
like those so much).The US and
China can go play their rivalry
and soft and proxy wars somewhere
else.

            > > > > > > warrantisall
Also European: Chat Control, DSA
            > > > > > > RobotToaster
How many European manufactured EVs
are there that aren't just
assembled from foreign batteries
and parts?

            > > > > > > speedgoose
I drove a VW ID recently and you
have plenty of physical buttons
everywhere you look as the driver,
yet some important features are
behind the touch screen.If you
ignore the ongoing nazi car brand
aspect, which is pretty hard to I
agree, I am not convinced the
traditional car brands you
mentioned are better value. And
they have a nazi past too. But
that's a while ago so it's okay.

            > > > > > > coryrc
Dieselgate stochastically killed a
lot of people recently.

            > > > > > > Lio
OK, if don't like German car
brands because of their past
there's still Renault (French) and
Nissan (Japanese).Both have
reasonably priced, well engineered
EVs in their range now.Both use
Android Auto and IMHO that works
very smoothly and without jank.
Plus they have physical
controls.Personally it's a
company's present and future
behaviour that I care most about
rather than stuff that happened in
the 1930s and 40s no matter how
horrific.

            > > > > > > speedgoose
I'm not sure Renault is a strong
improvement in terms of nazi
collaboration.You do you, the
Nissan Ariya or the Renault Scenic
aren't that bad indeed.

            > > > > > > f6v
What a load of bs, people have the
attention span of a fruit fly. Saw
one clown put a sticker "I got it
before Elon went crazy!" on their
Tesla in Copenhagen, but that's
about it. Danish are buying Teslas
like there's no tomorrow.

            > > > > > > Symbiote
Danes are buying EVs as fast as
they can before a possible tax
increase next year, but preferring
European and Chinese vehicles
where possible.If they can't get
something else, they settle for a
Tesla.Tesla had a 0.8% share of EV
sales in October 2026 in Denmark.

            > > > > > > vardump
Out of all cars sold in Denmark in
2026, 5.9% have been Teslas.

            > > > > > > retsibsi
> Tesla had a 0.8% share of EV
sales in October 2026 in
Denmark.Is this figure really for
EVs only? I don't find this
article[0] absolutely clear, but
in context it seems to be
referring to Tesla's share of all
passenger car sales:> Norway
remained a bright spot for Tesla.
The carmaker recorded its best
October on record and was the
country's top-selling car brand
with a 9.8% market share,
according to OFV. Chinese brands
continued to expand their
footprint, accounting for 22.5% of
new passenger car registrations,
their highest monthly share on
record.> [irrelevant quote]> By
contrast, Tesla's market share in
Denmark was only 0.73%, behind BYD
(002594.SZ), Leapmotor (9863.HK),
Xpeng (9868.HK), and SAIC-owned MG
(600104.SS), which captured
between 1.6% and 5.5% of the
market each.[0]
https://www.reuters.com/business/t
esla-registrations-surge-a...

            > > > > > > Symbiote
I think you're correct, but with
EV sales at over 80% of car sales
in Denmark it doesn't make much
difference.

            > > > > > > retsibsi
Thanks, I hadn't realised the EV
market was that big. You're of
course right that the difference
is therefore very small.

            > > > > > > msandford
It's super weird that the biggest
names in EVs total up to 10-15% of
market share, and also that EVs
are 80% of auto sales. What am I
missing?

            > > > > > > shoobiedoo
And politicians associated with
Chinese makers are clean as a
whistle?I've got no love for the
cringe machine that is Elon, but
c'mon. Would people really buy
from a Chinese maker over Tesla
based on some kind of political
stance?

            > > > > > > Lio
That's a good question that I
can't answer but for the sake of
argument there's plenty of other
EV manufacturers in the European
EV market at least.

            > > > > > > happymellon
Personally? Absolutely!The Chinese
haven't been spending a lot of
money to support right wing
authoritarian governments in my
country.Buying Tesla does. So you
don't have to be "clean as a
whistle" to be a massive
improvement.

            > > > > > > pepperoni_pizza
But they are heavily supporting
Russia which is definitely
spending money to support right
wing authoritarian governments in
you country.Worse than Musk?
Probably not. Better than Musk?
Also probably no.

            > > > > > > happymellon
Musk is also supporting Russia...
            > > > > > > Symbiote
At least regarding Denmark,
Chinese leaders and EV CEOs
haven't threatened to invade the
country.

          > > > > > adrianN
I'm under the impression that even
among the outliers that are people who
buy new cars instead of used, most buy
cars because they need to go places.
How many of those are willing to shell
out an extra 15k or so for something
as vague as software quality?

            > > > > > > budman1
if you change software quality to
just quality, toyota/honda will
answer that question.better
quality car is higher priced.

          > > > > > viraptor
There's very little difference between
Tesla and BYD day to day. I'm also
going to have Android Auto open
virtually all the time so couldn't see
any difference.

            > > > > > > MobiusHorizons
I think Tesla doesn't have Android
Auto or Apple CarPlay. I have
never driven one, but that's what
I read.

            > > > > > > viraptor
Hahaha, I've been in Teslas many
times (but not as a driver) and
thought I'm seeing Android Auto.
Which I guess proves my point.I
mean, for most people, you put
Spotify/Audible on, switch to the
map, go. There's a hard limit on
how much things can change.

          > > > > > kakacik
I would never pay twice the price of
the car for those, and tesla has made
some properly stupid hostile UI
decisions like moving turn lights into
steering wheel.Plus tesla is poisoned
by nazi owner who is extremely hostile
towards Europe for whatever reasons
and feels like he needs to interfere
in global politics, that brand is
burned for good regardless of
products. Something about having
actual morals and spine and voting
with wallet and not supporting evil
actors if you don't have to.

          > > > > > oblio
Honest question: what do people need
software quality for? What exactly are
they doing with their cars that need
all that in-car software? A phone
attached to the center column offers a
better software experience than any
car maker could offer. Are people
really paying that much to play games
on their car screens?

            > > > > > > kuerbel
No. I own a tesla and what I value
is the integrated dashcam and
sentry mode. Next comes route
planning (which is gmaps under the
hood but on a larger screen so
easier to see). Energy information
so that I can check how much I
used and when.

            > > > > > > drnick1
> integrated dashcam and sentry
mode.Unfortunately, that footage
does not stay on your
computer/car.https://www.drive.com
.au/news/tesla-shared-private-came
ra-re...

            > > > > > > kakacik
This is common in every major
chinese EV manufacturer now, maybe
apart from rock bottom cost
tier.I've sat in my friend's 600
HP Zeekr few months ago and saw
all you mention in some form or
another plus much, much more than
in my colleague's tesla 3.

            > > > > > > Symbiote
For an EV, planning a longer route
where a charging stop is
needed.Ideally that should work to
your preference, for example a
restaurant vs fast food nearby.

            > > > > > > bruce511
We're in a transition, but in the
near future you'll need you'll
plan less and basically just stop
when you need to.The capital cost
of an EV charging station is
absurdly low (compared to say
building a gas station) and
returns are high value with zero
effort.In other words they're a
high return profit center, which
means that pretty much every place
which is aimed at "passing long
distance traffic" will get one at
some point. We're already seeing
this play out a bit, but in 10
years they'll literally be
everywhere.

            > > > > > > HWR_14
Why would you want your EV to
route plan? My cellphone does so
in a convenient package.

            > > > > > > sandmn
That is if automaker supports
Apple CarPlay/Android Auto. Tesla
(and some other companies) does
not.

            > > > > > > oblio
You attach a phone holder to the
dash and use Google Maps. It's
plenty visible.

            > > > > > > speedgoose
It's more about having something
that works well than a crazy
feature set.

            > > > > > > oblio
I've navigated entire countries
with my phone, using Google Maps.

            > > > > > > speedgoose
You could have used a bicycle too.
        > > > > ErroneousBosh
> An entry level Tesla is kind of a luxury
car though.It's a luxury *price*. It is
not luxury *quality*.They're pretty crappy
cars for the price, lots of flimsy plastic
and bling.

      > > > goosejuice
> I think the main issue is that, at the low
end, the total cost of ownership of an entry
level Tesla or similar is rather high relative
to something like a hybrid CorollaAtlas Policy
has the 2024 models within a few grand of each
other at 7 years. It's not significant and the
Tesla is a much nicer car. Hybrids are
expensive to maintain.

      > > > numpad0
If EVs are "curiosity" in the US, it's dead. I
think almost all the countries EVs have been
successful are places that have lower
population densities than the global
average(not G7 or European average), including
the US and not including China.

      > > > Lutger
TCO in Europe for EV is beating ICE for a
while now, that isn't the case in the US? Why
not? Is it because Americans like big
inefficient cars more, or is gasoline that
much cheaper?

        > > > > HWR_14
Energy in general, whether gas or
electricity is cheaper in the US than in
the EU. Gas is far cheaper thanks to much
lower taxes. So energy costs are a lower
percentage of TCO either way. But even
with the recent price hikes, in the US (on
average) it's cheaper to use gas than
exclusively use fast chargers. Of course,
home charging is significantly cheaper
than either of those, but that means
owning a garage.The big difference is that
public charging is more than 3x home
charging in the US and (on average), less
than 2x home charging in the EU. As the
number of chargers goes up in the US
eventually that will change. Why the US
lags in charging infrastructure is a
different question, but is probably
because so many early adopters were able
to charge at home.

        > > > > fodkodrasz
Also larger distances, and everything laid
out inefficiently with bad zoning.
Basically motor-lobby ruined it for
them.Just bought a PHEV (Peugeot), and if
you can charge at home it runs rounds
around ICE cost-wise, eves with it being
relatively power-hungry compared to some
alternatives (but so comfortable and
sleek). With public charging it is
marginally cheaper than ICE, pricing of
public charge points swallowed the price
advantage, but I guess it is not free to
build that infrastructure, so its okay I
guess.

          > > > > > Geezus_42
Public charging is still significantly
cheaper than gas where I live in the
US, and Trump's war increased that
difference considerably.

        > > > > WarmWash
Gas in the US is cheap and distances are
far. Even with current "high" gas prices,
it's still around €0.90/l.

      > > > huijzer
I have owned a Tesla for a year but have now
switched back to petrol simply because of
range. I've spent way too many hours at fast
chargers. And this was in the Netherlands and
Germany. US distances are typically much
longer from what I understand.

        > > > > cheapcheerful
This sounds very strange to me. My Model 3
goes 550km on a single charge. I use the
charger at home and charge it like my
phone. I've used a fast charger twice in 3
years, only as a curiosity.I'm guessing
maybe your problem was that you live in an
apartment which doesn't provide a parking
space with electricity, so fast charge was
only option? Definintely an issue,
especially in some countries where the
usual home isn't a standalone single story
like Australia where I live.

        > > > > consp
You should also realise you are the
outlier. Most people travel far less than
the range of their vehicles (petrol or
EV).

          > > > > > gertrunde
This does tie into a good point - EVs
get surprisingly expensive if you
charge away from home.The price
difference between home charging vs a
fast charger can be extreme, 6-7p/unit
vs 80-90p/unit.

            > > > > > > ac29
That is highly regional. Where I
live, many public chargers are
cheaper than charging at home
because residential rates are so
high. On average, AC/L2 chargers
are roughly the same cost. Even
the most expensive fast chargers
are more like 2x home rates, not
10x.

            > > > > > > gniv
Yes but this too is temporary. If
you think how much cheaper it is
to install a charging station than
a gas station there is no reason
competition will not drive down
prices in the future.

            > > > > > > HWR_14
Except if you account for grid
costs. You can (and the military
practices) set up a gas station
with a tanker truck, a hose and
some dispensing pump anywhere. It
takes grid connections (and
capacity) to have a charging
station.

            > > > > > > kuerbel
I exclusively charge away from
home since I don't own a wallbox.
I also regularly drive from north
Germany to Switzerland, in my
model 3 Highland that means 2-3
charge stops. Which I would do
anyway.Usually I charge when I go
grocery shopping. I can't remember
the last time I drove to a
charging station just to charge.

          > > > > > kees99
Whle I obviously can't know exact GP's
situation in particular, statistically
speaking they are not necessarily an
outlier, for the region they are
from.Typical Dutch driving pattern is
strongly bimodal - a lot of everyday
short trips (think commuting), plus
several holiday trips per year -
Austria, south of France, Italy, you
name it. That would be the trips where
"too many hours at fast chargers"
would be a problem for me personally.

          > > > > > Brian_K_White
The fact that most people only drive a
few miles most of the time is true
exactly like most people don't have
house fires most of the time.It's a
true statement, they don't. Yet
everyone, not just people with jobs
and hobbies that cause fires, still
needs smoke alarms and fire
extinguishers and building codes that
demand multiple exits from bedrooms
etc.This "outlier" argument that a lot
of people think makes sense, doesn't.
It's completely invalid. Most people
could actually get by with a golf cart
most of the time. Except no they
can't, because most of the time isn't
good enough.

            > > > > > > bruce511
Your argument is funny to me
because we don't have any
regulations here for those
things.In my house there are no
smoke alarms, or fire
extinguishers, and all the
bedrooms have a single exit. And
I'd say we're pretty typical in
this area.Which is not to say
those things wouldn't be a good
idea, it's just that the attitude
towards house fires may be more
local than you assume.

        > > > > Lio
Out of interest how much range do you
need?BMW just launched an i3 with a 567
mile range. Is that enough?Personally I
think I'd be pretty happy with 300 to 400
miles.Range will increase over
time.There's still lots of efficiency
improvements to be made like replacing the
motor, differential and breaking systems
with in-wheel combined brake/motor
units.We will get to a point where EV
range is greater than on ICE cars.

          > > > > > HWR_14
I want a cheap EV with a 100 mile
range for local errands that I use for
80-90% of driving. Us far fewer
batteries and make it cheap enough
that it's a second car and it'll solve
any concerns about range anxiety.

          > > > > > MobiusHorizons
> replacing the motor, differential
and breaking systems with in-wheel
combined brake/motor units.There are a
lot of drawbacks to this strategy btw.
Unsprung weight gets a lot worse, and
expensive high voltage parts become
much more exposed to elements and
shock loads. The benefits seem
unlikely to outweigh the drawbacks for
most applications.

            > > > > > > Lio
> Unsprung weight gets a lot
worseNot necessarily. Where it
gets interesting are the
prototypes with lower unsprung
weight than the equivalent braking
system.They're not there yet but
it shows there's definitely new
avenues to explore.

        > > > > Lutger
I don't own a car, never have, but for
everybody I know who has an EV (in the
Netherlands) this is not an issue at all.
After you need a recharge people need a
coffee break too, and 20 minutes fast
charging is enough to get you there. Maybe
you have different needs or don't take
breaks from driving that much?

          > > > > > Revanche1367
I don't know about Europe, but it's
quite typical in the US to drive for
1-1.5 hours for a regular commute. I
drive to grad school 2-3 times a week
for ~50 minutes typically for example,
can easily be an hour on some days, no
stops at all because that's a
relatively short distance. For longer
journeys, we typically don't stop
except maybe every 2-3 hours. We would
only stop for 20 minutes or more for a
lunch break, not coffee, and once in
the middle of a 5-8 hour road trip
with smaller 5-10 minute stops
sparsely placed.

            > > > > > > ac29
> I don't know about Europe, but
it's quite typical in the US to
drive for 1-1.5 hours for a
regular commute.The average in the
US is 27 mins:
https://www.census.gov/topics/empl
oyment/commuting/guidance/...Longe
r commutes aren't uncommon, I
wouldnt call them typical.

            > > > > > > HWR_14
When 1/6 of jobs are
work-from-home, the mean is a
pretty bad statistic to use. 9.5%
of Americans (up from the previous
year) had a 60 minute plus commute
(one way).I wanted a
median/quartile breakdown, but
that seems harder to find.

            > > > > > > Revanche1367
It's not typical in the sense of
the US average sure, but "typical"
doesn't necessarily imply anything
about average, it can just as
easily mean "normal", "common",
"expected," etc. Where I live,
it's quite common to hear about
not only people driving long
distances for work, train commutes
are often about as long.

            > > > > > > Geezus_42
Then you would get plenty of range
just starting with a full charge
and plugging it in while you take
your pit stops. I make a 3 hour
drive, about the first hour is in
dense traffic, once a week and I
only have to stop to charge if the
car is below ~90%.

        > > > > hdgvhicv
I do 35,000km a year / more than twice the
average in the U.K - and have used a fast
charger 5 times this year.

        > > > > fc417fc802
> US distances are typically much longer
from what I understand.Ehh that's
complicated. They're much _much_ longer
once you get out into the sticks. In the
suburbs I imagine it varies. But in urban
areas AFAIK they're fairly similar and as
it happens those are the areas where you
benefit from EVs the most while also being
where people with highly paid jobs tend to
be located.

      > > > awestroke
The US banned the import and sales of chinese
EVs like BYD. Who knows what american roads
would have looked like otherwise?Only 16-20%
of cars on the road in the "u"s are trucks, so
not really relevant anyway.

        > > > > inemesitaffia
I'm pretty sure the Ford CEO owns a
Chinese car

          > > > > > bell-cot
Roughly
yes:https://finance.yahoo.com/sectors/
technology/articles/didn-t...But the
rules may differ for those of us who
are not major automotive CEO's.

      > > > dzhiurgis
For sure and kinda understandable (i get - i
just don't get it, like the gun thing). But
Toyota does sell different cars for different
markets, why can't they EVs for markets that
want them. It took them 1.5 decades to make EV
that's finally competes with others makers.

    > > anovikov
It means firing a lot of people (labor intensity
of EV production is much lower) and Japanese
automakers can't do that for a multitude of
reasons. They are cooked, they will just go out of
business. Fast.

      > > > gniv
Germany is currently going through this
transition. It will be interesting to see what
happens.

        > > > > anovikov
They are just failing, not transitioning.
Old factories and brands closing down, new
ones not appearing, people retiring or
becoming jobless. Unions prevented
transition.

    > > Geezus_42
Same with US and European automakers. Guess they
shouldn't have listened to all those oil
lobbyists.

  > rokweom
Wasn't the whole point of outsourcing production of as
many parts as possible to reduce costs compared to
manufacturing them in-house?